Last Tuesday, the Manhattan U.S. Attorney announced the arrest of Devyani Khobragade, a prominent Indian diplomat, for allegedly falsifying documents related to the domestic worker she employed through an A-3 visa, who has come forward with details about low pay and poor labor conditions at Khobragade’s home. Much of the media surrounding this case has focused on the unfair treatment of Khobragade and the Indian government’s outrage. But what’s missing from the conversation is the context – exploitation of migrant domestic workers is not unusual. Khobragade was clearly mistreated by U.S. officers, but what about the abuse that migrant domestic workers live through every day? Khobragade, like hundreds of other consular officers, Diplomats, and international officials, was granted the privilege of bringing over a domestic worker to care for her home and family under the U.S. A-3/G-5 visa program. The Department of State, which oversees and monitors this visa program, requires employers and workers to have written contracts that detail wages, hours, working conditions, in addition to in-person interviews and education about human trafficking and worker rights in the United States. Yet as this case shows, dishonest employers can find ways to undermine these protections. There are more than 52 million domestic workers around the world. Many of them are migrants coming from places like India, Nepal, the Philippines, and Indonesia. They travel all over the world to work in the homes of wealthy families and diplomats. Those who come to the United States enter a system where they’ll face layers of adversity just going to work each day. As mostly women of color and immigrants they will contend with discrimination based on gender, race, class, and immigration status. As domestic workers, they will be excluded from several important labor protections like the right to organize. The fact that their work is performed behind closed doors, in a country that highly values privacy and vehemently resists government oversight, makes it even harder for exploitation to be recognized and reported by even the most active citizens. Domestic workers on these special diplomatic visas must contend with the additional risk of working for employers who have control over the visa, who can easily access and threaten the worker’s family in the home country, and who frequently avert meaningful punishment when they violate rules – whether through settlements, quiet exits, or no consequence at all. It takes incredible bravery to break through these layers of adversity and come forward to get help. Yet rather than being hailed as heroes or even uplifted as survivors worthy of empathy – migrant domestic workers are too often vilified, especially in the media of their home countries. Sometimes the workers are even sued or accused of a crime. In this case, media is focused on the treatment of the employer rather than the exploitation of the domestic worker she employed. We’ve heard reports that the Indian government and media are outraged at the State Department for this arrest. This is unacceptable. Among its many functions, the State Department is tasked with protecting all workers who travel to the United States to work on these visas – which means they have to enforce our laws and arrest people who blatantly violate them, regardless of rank or gender. The treatment of Khobragade during her arrest raises serious concerns for us, and our international allies, but it is our belief this cannot be used as an excuse to ignore the deeper questions raised by the case. We are grateful that this investigation was initiated and followed it through – too often, it is the international norm to ignore domestic worker abuse. Congress, media, activists, and workers should stand by this worker, and stand by the State Department for taking action against the employer.
- Do We Need a Maximum Wage?
- Gender Pay Gap Drives Inequality
- Standing Before Congress, Pope Francis Calls Out the ‘Industry of Death’
- What Can ‘Star Trek’ Teach Us About American Exceptionalism?
- The Guardian Reveals the West Ignored Russian Offer to Depose Assad in 2012
- What America Owes the Refugees Pouring Into Europe
Stay in touch with our community of public scholars and get the latest cutting edge progressive analysis and commentary.
Want to see more like this?
Support Tiffany's work by chipping in. You can make a difference.